Skip to main content
Garden Route Mediation

Water and irrigation disputes

Water turns, shared dams, furrows and pipelines: disputes between neighbours who will still share the same water next year.

What these disputes look like

Water disputes are rarely about one incident. They build up over dry seasons, and by the time someone phones an attorney the neighbours have often stopped greeting each other. Typical issues are:

  • water turns that are not kept, or that one side says were changed;
  • shared dams, furrows, weirs and pipelines, and who pays to maintain them;
  • a pump, a pipeline or a servitude that crosses someone else's land;
  • boreholes and their effect on a neighbour's water;
  • new plantings or dams upstream that change what reaches the farms below;
  • old arrangements between previous owners that nobody wrote down.

Why mediation suits water

You cannot move your farm, and neither can your neighbour. Whatever a court decides, you will still take water from the same river, furrow or dam next year. A solution that both of you helped to design is far more likely to hold in a dry year than one imposed on you.

Mediation also lets you bring in the practical detail a courtroom has little patience for: who opens which sluice on which day, how a repair is shared, what happens when the dam is low.

How I approach it

I speak to each side first to understand the water system and the history. Where it helps, we work from maps, schedules and the paperwork you already have. On the mediation day we meet at a neutral venue, in joint sessions and private sessions, and work towards a practical arrangement. If you agree, it is written up and signed on the day.

I am a mediator, not a water engineer or a lawyer. If you need technical or legal advice to settle a point, you can bring your adviser, or we can pause so that you can get it.

What you can rely on

The process is confidential and without prejudice. You decide the outcome. And if you do not agree, every other route is still open to you.

Common questions

Several farms share the same furrow. Can everyone take part?

Yes. Mediation works with more than two parties, and for shared water it is often the only way to get everyone who is affected around one table. [TODO: George to confirm how fees are shared between several parties]

Does mediation replace the water authorities or a water user association?

No. Mediation deals with the disagreement between the people involved. Any agreement you reach still has to fit within the law and your existing water rights. [TODO: George to check wording]

Can we mediate on the farm?

Mediations are usually held at a neutral venue in George or Oudtshoorn, or online via Microsoft Teams. [TODO: George to confirm whether he will visit a site or meet elsewhere]

  • Farm lease disputes

    When owner and tenant disagree about rent, maintenance, improvements or the end of the lease, mediation can settle it before the season is lost.

Talk it through first

A short call costs nothing and commits you to nothing. Whatever you tell me is treated as confidential.